Harsh Critic

I am an extremely critical reader. There is very little that I find I like anymore…or perhaps (from my point of view) there is so much to not like out there. And to have to read them…even first pages…would be an epic failure on my part.

Simply put, I could never be an editor (or reviewer). I’d reject everything. Everything but that one piece.


And maybe that’s where most editors come from! I’ve heard from many essentially the same thing: that they’re just looking for reasons to reject us. They have so many manuscripts to pore over that they’re looking for any reason to reject…even if you spelled their name incorrectly (I wouldn’t do that—this happens too frequently to me from the rank-and-file—and I’m not that nasty). But I think I’m beginning to see their point, even if they are paid to read our stuff. At first I was quite put off by that statement…but, yeah, I think I finally get it.

It’s not that I only find my own work “good” or interesting…it’s just that most of what I find I just don’t like, and it’s not always about the writing itself. It’s what the writing’s about. There are some writers I know who are damned good writers…I just don’t like their work (stories). That is nothing against them! They’re doing well and I love that! I just seem to have a limited scope of interest, you could say.

And, yes, I can usually tell if a story is “good” on its own, even if I don’t like it. The writing’s there…the world building…the characters…and finally, the story. It’s all about the story for me.


If I don’t like your work…that doesn’t mean it isn’t good!

I just could never be an editor.

About fpdorchak

Speculative and paranormal fiction author. Please check out my website: https://www.fpdorchak.com/. Thank you for stopping by!
This entry was posted in Book Reviews, Books, Reviews, Writing and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Harsh Critic

  1. Karen Lin says:

    I have a stack of books on my nightstand that I dread opening, in part because I suspect most of them I won’t enjoy. I rarely force myself past a couple of chapters. Time is becoming too precious for me… so, I understand what you mean. For me, however, it is usually more about the characters than about story. I’ll go out on a PC limb and speculate that there may be a difference… in general… between the sexes. Don’t hang me folks, it’s just a theory.

    • fpdorchak says:

      No problems, here, Inky! 🙂 We all have our preferences! I also will no longer force myself to finish a book if I just cannot get into it. More power those who get publishing deals!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.